- In June 2025, A. J. T. v. Osseo Area Schools ended the special 'bad faith or gross misjudgment' test for students' ADA and 504 claims.
- A 2023 ruling, Luna Perez, held IDEA exhaustion does not block ADA suits seeking compensatory damages.
- IEP and 504 teams can include supports like sensory breaks and permission to stim.
- Document every request, ask for decisions in writing, and talk with an attorney before suing.
You have been in IEP meetings where the school says no to accommodations your autistic child needs. If you ever took that fight beyond IDEA to a disability discrimination claim, some courts made it much harder to win than it should have been.
In June 2025, the Supreme Court changed that, unanimously.
Here is what happened, how it fits with an earlier ruling, and what you should do now. This is general information, not legal advice. Talk with a special education attorney or advocate about your child's situation.
The 2025 Ruling: The Same Standard as Everyone Else
On June 12, 2025, the Supreme Court decided A. J. T. v. Osseo Area Schools. A. J. T. is a teenager with a rare form of epilepsy whose school district refused her parents' requests for evening instruction. Some lower courts, including the Eighth Circuit in her case, had required students bringing ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims about their education to prove the school acted with "bad faith or gross misjudgment," a much higher bar than other disability discrimination claims.
The Court, in an opinion by Chief Justice Roberts for a unanimous Court, held that schoolchildren bringing ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims related to their education are not required to make that heightened showing. They are subject to the same standards that apply in other disability discrimination contexts.
Translation: when a school fails to accommodate a disabled student, the student's ADA and Section 504 claims are judged by the same rules as anyone else's, not a special, harder test for schools.
The 2023 Ruling on IDEA Exhaustion
A separate unanimous decision, Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools (March 21, 2023), addressed the administrative process. IDEA generally requires families to go through its due process procedures first when they file a lawsuit under another federal law "seeking relief that is also available" under IDEA. The Court held that this exhaustion requirement does not block an ADA lawsuit seeking compensatory damages, because money damages are not something IDEA can provide.
That is narrower than "you can always skip the hearing." If you are asking for things IDEA can provide, such as changes to services or placement, the exhaustion requirement can still apply. An attorney can tell you which path fits your goals.
What Your Child Is Legally Entitled To
Under IDEA, your child has the right to a Free Appropriate Public Education in the Least Restrictive Environment, and to an individualized IEP with special education and related services.
Section 504 and Title II of the ADA, as the Court's 2025 opinion summarizes, protect qualified individuals with disabilities from being excluded from, denied the benefits of, or discriminated against in public programs, including public schools.
In practice, IEP and 504 teams can include supports such as sensory breaks, a quiet workspace, communication supports, modified assignments, anxiety accommodations, and permission to stim, when a child needs them.
What To Do Now
Document everything. Email the school with every accommodation request. Include why your child needs it. Save every response.
Know what the IEP includes. Check for sensory breaks, quiet workspace, communication support, stim-friendly environment, modified social expectations, and anxiety accommodations. If your child needs any of these and does not have them, that is a gap.
Use clear language in IEP meetings. "My child needs this accommodation to access education. I would like the school's decision in writing." When a school refuses to change your child's services or placement, IDEA requires Prior Written Notice. You do not have to be aggressive. Just be clear.
Know when to escalate. If the school repeatedly denies documented accommodation needs, you can use IDEA's dispute options, such as mediation, a state complaint, or a due process hearing, and you can talk with an attorney about whether an ADA or Section 504 claim fits your situation. After A. J. T., those claims no longer face a special "bad faith or gross misjudgment" test.
The Bottom Line
Your autistic child deserves accommodations that let them learn without forcing them to hide who they are. As of June 2025, the Supreme Court has made clear that disabled students' discrimination claims against schools are judged by the same standards as everyone else's.
Use it.
---
Resources
- A. J. T. v. Osseo Area Schools (2025), Supreme Court opinion - Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools (2023), Supreme Court opinion - Wrightslaw.com, Education law resource for parents - Autistic Self Advocacy Network: autisticadvocacy.org - Your state's Parent Training and Information Center (parentcenterhub.org locator)
More from WeBearish
- How to Prepare for an IEP Meeting, What to say and what to do when the school says no - Autism in Public Schools: What Goes Wrong and What Helps - Join the WeBearish Community, No tragedy narratives.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the June 2025 Supreme Court ruling change for autistic students?
On June 12, 2025, in A. J. T. v. Osseo Area Schools, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that students bringing ADA and Rehabilitation Act claims related to their education do not have to prove "bad faith or gross misjudgment." Their claims are judged by the same standards as other disability discrimination claims. A separate 2023 ruling, Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools, held that IDEA's exhaustion requirement does not block an ADA lawsuit seeking compensatory damages.
What is my autistic child legally entitled to at school?
Under IDEA, your child has the right to a Free Appropriate Public Education in the Least Restrictive Environment and an individualized IEP with special education and related services. Section 504 and Title II of the ADA protect students with disabilities from exclusion and discrimination in public school programs. In practice, IEP and 504 teams can include supports such as sensory breaks, a quiet workspace, communication supports, and permission to stim when a child needs them.
What should I do now to protect my child's rights?
Document everything by emailing the school with each accommodation request, the reason it is needed, and saving every response. Check whether the IEP includes supports like sensory breaks, quiet workspace, and anxiety accommodations, and ask for decisions in writing, since IDEA requires Prior Written Notice when a school refuses a change. If the school repeatedly denies documented needs, use IDEA's dispute options and talk with an attorney about whether an ADA or Section 504 claim fits.